Justice for the Dead, Responsibility to the Living

There are names and tragedies in Sonoma County that need little explanation.

Polly Klaas. Deputy Frank Trejo. The seven people murdered by Ramon Salcido.

Each evokes memories of terrible violence, of lives taken and families forever changed. For those who lived through these tragedies, the passage of time has not erased their impact.

The 1993 kidnapping and murder of 12-year-old Polly Klaas from her Petaluma home shocked the nation. In 1989, Ramon Salcido murdered seven people, including members of his own family, leaving Sonoma County struggling to comprehend the magnitude of the violence. In 1995, Sheriff's Deputy Frank Trejo was murdered in the line of duty by Robert Walter Scully.

These crimes remain part of our community's history. They also remind us that behind every homicide statistic lies a human life, a grieving family, and a community forced to confront the consequences of violence.

On Nov. 5, Gov. Gavin Newsom announced his intention to commute the death sentences of all 548 people currently on death row in California, replacing those sentences with life imprisonment without the possibility of parole.

Sonoma County Sheriff Eddie Engram responded with a heartfelt Facebook statement opposing the proposal. He spoke from the perspective of a law enforcement leader whose department still carries the loss of a murdered deputy.

He described the suffering endured by victims' families, the difficult work of law enforcement officers who investigated these crimes, and the importance of respecting sentences imposed by juries and courts.

"Justice must mean something," he wrote.

On that fundamental point, I agree.

Justice must mean something. Victims and their families deserve respect, compassion, and accountability. Those responsible for these horrific crimes must be held accountable for their actions.

The sheriff's statement and the wide range of public comments that followed offer an opportunity to ask a question that reaches beyond the immediate controversy.

Is justice measured primarily by the severity of punishment we impose after violence occurs, or must it also be measured by what we do to prevent the next tragedy?

I believe the answer requires us to think more broadly about justice, public safety, and our responsibility to both the dead and the living. As Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel observed, "In a free society, some are guilty, but all are responsible." His words remind us that while individuals must be held accountable for their crimes, we share a collective responsibility to prevent violence and protect human life.

Understanding What the Governor Has Proposed

Before examining those questions, it is important to understand what Newsom's announcement means and what it does not mean.

The governor is seeking to replace every existing death sentence in California with life imprisonment without the possibility of parole.

The individuals affected will remain incarcerated. Their convictions will not be overturned. They will not become eligible for parole, and the commutations will not erase restitution orders.

The decision does not pardon anyone, excuse their crimes, or repeal California's death penalty law.

The decision is not yet final. Under the California Constitution, the governor must obtain a favorable recommendation from at least four justices of the California Supreme Court before commuting the sentences of people convicted of more than one felony. That requirement applies to 382 of the 548 individuals.

The California Supreme Court has now invited legal briefs addressing the governor's request. Interested parties have until Nov. 24 to submit proposed briefs, and Newsom may respond by Dec. 4. The justices have not yet decided whether to recommend the commutations.

California has not carried out an execution since 2006. Newsom formally imposed a moratorium on executions in 2019, although death sentences remained in place.

In practical terms, the governor is proposing to replace a punishment that California has not carried out in two decades with a sentence that requires those convicted to spend the rest of their lives in prison.

That distinction matters.

A sentence of life without parole is not freedom. Under current law, it requires the person to remain in prison for life.

Some people believe that punishment is insufficient for the most horrific crimes. Others believe that lifelong imprisonment provides accountability without requiring the government to take another life.

Both perspectives deserve consideration.

But neither should obscure the fact that these individuals will remain imprisoned.

Justice Through the Eyes of Victims

Sheriff Engram's strongest argument concerns the suffering of victims' families.

He reminds us that families endured investigations, criminal trials, sentencing hearings, and years of appeals. Many placed their trust in a judicial system that promised accountability for those responsible.

Changing those sentences can feel like changing the rules after families have spent decades relying on them.

For some, it may feel like the justice they were promised has been taken away.

I understand that concern.

During more than three decades in law enforcement, I came to appreciate that the consequences of violent crime extend far beyond the immediate victim.

A homicide does not end when investigators leave the crime scene or when a jury returns its verdict.

Parents lose children. Children grow up without parents. Spouses lose lifelong companions. Families struggle with trauma, financial hardship, unanswered questions, and memories that can remain painfully vivid for decades.

Police officers, firefighters, emergency medical personnel, and others who respond to these tragedies can carry their own emotional burdens.

The criminal justice system has an obligation to acknowledge these experiences.

But there is another important reality.

Victims and surviving family members do not all define justice in the same way.

The Klaas family offers a particularly powerful example.

Polly's father, Marc Klaas, has been an outspoken critic of Newsom's death penalty decisions. He has described the governor's actions as a betrayal of victims and their families.

His anger deserves to be heard and respected.

Yet Polly's sisters, Jess and Annie Nichol, see it differently.

Both oppose capital punishment. Jess has explained that she once believed Polly's murderer deserved execution but came to recognize that another death would not contribute to her healing or make the public safer.

Annie has spoken about the harm caused when victims' suffering becomes tied to increasingly punitive criminal justice policies.

According to reporting by the San Francisco Chronicle, the sisters met with Newsom in October and discussed their views on capital punishment and victims' needs. The governor subsequently described that conversation as particularly influential.

Consider what this means.

Members of the same family, grieving the loss of the same child, have reached profoundly different conclusions about what justice requires.

Neither perspective diminishes the family's loss.

Neither should be dismissed because it does not conform to someone else's beliefs about punishment.

The same is true of other homicide survivors.

Some believe execution is essential to accountability. Others find that the prolonged appeals associated with capital punishment repeatedly reopen painful wounds. Still others struggle with conflicting feelings that evolve over time.

A Nov. 7 CalMatters report documents the anguish of surviving family members who feel betrayed by Newsom's decision, alongside the perspective of a grieving sister who does not blame the governor.

In the days since the announcement, families representing 50 murder victims have publicly supported the commutations. They urged that $150 million in anticipated death penalty expenditures be redirected toward trauma recovery centers and flexible assistance for survivors. Their proposal is not an enacted budget commitment, but it raises a question central to this essay: What would meaningful investment in survivors look like?

These are not competing claims to whose grief is more legitimate.

They are reminders that grief is deeply personal.

No public official or organization can capture the full range of experiences and beliefs among victims' families. We should listen to survivors even when their conclusions differ from our own.

We can honor their suffering without assuming their experiences produce a single political or moral conclusion.

And we can recognize that respecting victims requires more than defending a particular sentence.

The Rule of Law and the Question of Trust

Sheriff Engram also raises an important concern about the integrity of the judicial process.

California voters rejected proposals to abolish the death penalty in both 2012 and 2016. In 2016, voters also approved Proposition 66, intended to expedite capital cases.

Those decisions reflect the expressed preferences of voters who participated in those elections.

The death sentences at issue were imposed through criminal proceedings under California law, often after extensive appeals and judicial review.

It is reasonable to ask whether a governor should change hundreds of those sentences through executive clemency.

Yet that is not the only constitutional principle at work.

The power to commute sentences is itself part of California's constitutional framework.

Executive clemency is an established part of our constitutional system. It recognizes that even lawful sentences may be reconsidered, subject to the safeguards the Constitution requires.

The question is therefore both legal and ethical: What does the Constitution permit, and is the governor exercising his authority wisely, transparently, and with sufficient consideration for the people affected?

The disagreement has moved beyond social media. On Nov. 12, Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman supported a legal challenge to the blanket commutations. Victims' advocates and law enforcement organizations have objected as well, arguing that families' rights and individual circumstances deserve closer consideration.

Other law enforcement and prosecutorial leaders, including Contra Costa County District Attorney Diana Becton and former Los Angeles County District Attorney Gil Garcetti, have supported the commutations because they believe the death penalty consumes resources that could do more to protect the public. This is a genuine disagreement among people who have devoted their careers to public safety.

Newsom has explained his moral opposition to capital punishment and his concern about administering an irreversible penalty through an imperfect legal system.

In his Nov. 5 letter to Californians, he acknowledges the suffering caused by those sentenced to death and recognizes that his decision may reopen painful memories.

He has also met with victims and surviving family members during his time in office.

Yet some families have reported feeling excluded from the process or learning about the decision through news reports.

Those concerns should not be brushed aside.

California has procedures to notify registered victims and provide services. According to the governor's office, registered survivors will be notified when the commutations take effect. Those procedures matter, but so does the timing and quality of communication. Families should be treated with care before, during, and after a decision of this magnitude.

A decision can be constitutionally authorized and still be implemented in a manner that unnecessarily harms people.

Newsom's moral conviction does not relieve him of the responsibility to treat surviving families with dignity.

At the same time, it is important to recognize that life imprisonment without parole remains a serious punishment, not the abandonment of accountability or a return to freedom.

Public trust depends on more than a decision's outcome.

It depends on the process, the transparency of those responsible, and the respect shown to people whose lives are affected.

Does Harsher Punishment Make Us Safer?

Among the comments responding to Sheriff Engram's post, one statement captured a widely held belief:

"Strict punishment promotes a safer society. Lax punishment promotes criminal behavior."

It is an appealing argument.

It suggests a straightforward relationship between punishment and safety: The harsher the penalty, the less likely someone will commit a crime.

But decades of criminological research tell a more complicated story.

The National Institute of Justice, the research arm of the U.S. Department of Justice, has found that the certainty of being caught is a substantially more effective deterrent than the severity of punishment.

In other words, people are generally more likely to be influenced by believing they will be apprehended than by the possibility of receiving an exceptionally harsh sentence.

That does not mean punishment is unnecessary.

It means we should distinguish between punishment as a form of accountability and punishment as a crime-prevention strategy.

The distinction is especially important when discussing the death penalty.

In 2012, the National Research Council examined the available research on whether capital punishment deters homicide.

Its report, Deterrence and the Death Penalty, concluded that existing studies could not reliably determine whether the death penalty increases, decreases, or has no effect on homicide rates.

The research did not establish that capital punishment has no deterrent effect.

It established that claims of a deterrent benefit have not been reliably demonstrated.

That is an important difference.

For policymakers, the practical question is whether executing someone provides a greater public safety benefit than permanently incarcerating that person.

At present, the research does not provide convincing evidence of such an additional benefit.

And that should matter when government is making decisions about life, death, and the use of public resources.

There is also the issue of wrongful convictions.

Our criminal justice system is administered by human beings. Investigators, prosecutors, defense attorneys, witnesses, experts, jurors and judges can make mistakes.

Evidence can be misunderstood. Witnesses can be mistaken. False testimony can influence a verdict. Scientific methods once considered reliable can later be questioned.

These failures do not describe every criminal case, and they should not be used to dismiss the enormous care that many professionals bring to their work.

But the possibility of error is real.

An unjust imprisonment is devastating. When new evidence establishes innocence, the legal system may at least have an opportunity to correct the conviction and release the person.

An execution cannot be reversed.

That reality deserves consideration even when the crimes being discussed are so horrific that sympathy for the perpetrator seems impossible.

Protecting the innocent is not an act of leniency toward the guilty.

It is a foundation of justice.

What We Owe Those Left Behind

One of the most troubling aspects of the death penalty debate is how much attention is directed toward the person convicted of murder and how comparatively little attention is sometimes given to the continuing needs of surviving families.

The public discussion becomes a contest over whether an offender should live or die.

Meanwhile, survivors may still be struggling to rebuild their lives.

They may need counseling, financial assistance, help navigating the criminal justice system, or support in caring for children who have lost a parent.

Some experience lasting anxiety, depression, or post-traumatic stress. Others struggle with the ordinary demands of daily life while carrying extraordinary grief.

The needs do not necessarily disappear after a trial, a sentencing hearing or the exhaustion of an appeal.

Nor do they disappear because an offender is executed.

If we are serious about honoring victims, we should ask whether our victim assistance systems provide the support families need, not simply during the first weeks or months after a tragedy, but for as long as those needs persist.

Are survivors able to obtain affordable, trauma-informed mental health services?

Do they receive clear, timely information about their cases?

Are children and other family members offered appropriate support?

Do victims have meaningful opportunities to express their views without being pressured to adopt a particular position on punishment?

Do we invest sufficiently in organizations that help families navigate grief, trauma and the practical consequences of violent crime?

And when a public official makes a decision that could reopen painful memories, do we communicate with compassion and respect?

These questions deserve as much attention as the sentences imposed on those responsible.

A justice system should not require survivors to continually revisit the worst moments of their lives simply to feel heard.

Nor should a person's access to support depend on whether they support or oppose capital punishment.

Victims deserve more than a sentence. They deserve a sustained commitment to their well-being.

That commitment should be a central measure of how well our criminal justice system serves the people most deeply affected by violence.

From Punishment to Prevention

This brings me to a responsibility that can be overshadowed when public discussion centers on punishment: preventing the next act of violence.

For much of my professional life, I have worked in law enforcement and violence prevention. Those experiences have reinforced my belief that enforcement and accountability are essential elements of public safety.

But they have also taught me that neither is sufficient on its own.

By the time someone has been murdered, the criminal justice system is responding to a tragedy that has already occurred.

Investigators can identify those responsible. Prosecutors can pursue convictions. Courts can impose appropriate punishment.

Those responsibilities are important.

But none can restore the life that was lost.

That is why violence prevention must be considered an equally important public responsibility.

It requires us to look beyond individual criminal acts and examine the conditions, behaviors, and circumstances that increase the risk of violence.

It requires early intervention, effective law enforcement, access to behavioral health services, family support, and meaningful opportunities for young people.

It also requires recognizing that different forms of violence demand different responses.

The tragedies Sheriff Engram references remind us of several distinct public safety challenges.

The murder of Polly Klaas raises enduring concerns about protecting children, identifying dangerous offenders, and preventing sexual violence.

The killings committed by Ramon Salcido remind us of the devastating consequences of extreme violence within families and communities.

The murder of Deputy Frank Trejo underscores the dangers faced by law enforcement officers and the importance of assessing and managing serious threats to public safety.

We cannot know whether different prevention strategies would have altered the outcomes in these particular cases.

It would be inappropriate to suggest that any specific program or intervention could have prevented these tragedies.

But we can learn from the broader categories of violence they represent.

We can strengthen systems that identify and respond to domestic violence before it becomes deadly.

We can improve coordination among schools, child protection agencies, law enforcement, and community organizations when children face serious threats.

We can intervene with individuals and groups at elevated risk of becoming involved in violence, using strategies informed by credible research and local conditions.

We can expand access to trauma-informed mental health services, improve firearm safety, and reduce opportunities for violence to escalate.

And we can ensure that people returning from incarceration receive appropriate supervision, support, and accountability.

None of these approaches guarantees that violence will never occur.

But comprehensive prevention strategies offer opportunities to reduce risks before irreversible harm takes place.

Communities should evaluate those strategies carefully, sustain what works and change what does not.

This is the philosophy behind the comprehensive violence prevention approaches I have spent years advocating.

Effective public safety requires prevention, intervention, enforcement, and reentry working together.

These are not competing philosophies.

They are complementary responsibilities.

We should not be forced to choose between holding someone accountable for murder and investing in programs that may prevent another murder.

A responsible public safety strategy must do both.

The Cost of Punishment and the Value of Prevention

There is another dimension to this discussion that warrants attention: public resources.

Capital punishment is expensive, particularly because death sentences require extensive legal review and specialized procedures.

California has spent billions of dollars maintaining its capital punishment system since reinstating the death penalty in 1978, while carrying out only 13 executions.

A 2026 California judicial branch budget document cites an earlier estimate of approximately $150 million in annual death penalty costs, while more recent analyses have placed capital-case legal expenditures at roughly $200 million annually.

These figures are estimates using different assumptions and accounting methods. They should not be treated as precise predictions of the savings from Newsom's proposed commutations.

People serving life sentences still require housing, medical care, security, and other services. Some legal costs may continue, and any savings would emerge over time.

But the broader question remains.

Are we allocating public resources in ways that produce the greatest possible benefit to public safety?

That is not simply a budget question.

It is a question about our priorities.

Imagine the potential benefit of sustained investments in evidence-based violence intervention, domestic violence prevention, youth development, mental health care, and services for surviving families.

Some investments may produce measurable reductions in violence. Others may improve the quality of life for people who have already experienced harm.

Both are legitimate public benefits.

Of course, savings from capital punishment would not automatically be redirected to these purposes. Doing so would require deliberate policy and budget decisions.

And we should not pretend that every prevention program is effective merely because its intentions are good.

Programs must be evaluated. Results must be measured. Public funds must be spent responsibly.

But if we are willing to devote substantial resources to punishment after a homicide, we should be equally willing to examine what investments might reduce the likelihood of another homicide occurring.

That is what a prevention-oriented public safety system should do.

A Broader Definition of Justice

Sheriff Engram and I share important common ground. We both believe the lives taken by violence must be remembered and the people responsible must be held accountable.

His statement conveys the lasting pain of these crimes and his commitment to the families and colleagues who continue to grieve.

I respect that commitment, even though we arrive at different conclusions about the death penalty.

I also understand why some victims' families believe the governor's action diminishes the sentences imposed by juries.

For them, the death penalty represents a measure of justice that they fought for and trusted the system to deliver.

Their disappointment should not be minimized.

My own conclusion is that changing a death sentence to life without parole can preserve meaningful accountability without dishonoring the people whose lives were taken.

There is a difference between ensuring that someone is held accountable and insisting that accountability requires execution.

There is also a difference between respecting a jury's decision and recognizing that our constitutional system provides procedures for reconsidering sentences.

These distinctions are not evidence of indifference toward crime.

They reflect the complexity of administering justice in a democratic society.

I believe we can condemn horrific acts of violence without abandoning our commitment to human dignity.

We can demand accountability while acknowledging that our criminal justice system is imperfect.

We can honor surviving family members who support the death penalty while respecting those who oppose it.

We can recognize that those responsible for serious crimes must face meaningful consequences without assuming that increasingly severe punishment will necessarily make our communities safer.

None of this requires us to defend every aspect of Newsom's decision.

His use of executive authority deserves scrutiny. His engagement with victims and surviving families deserves examination. The legal process must be respected.

These are legitimate questions of leadership and accountability.

The controversy can also challenge all of us, including law enforcement leaders, elected officials, victim advocates and community organizations, to consider what more we can do together.

Instead of allowing the discussion to end with opposing positions on capital punishment, we could use this moment to strengthen our collective commitment to those affected by violence.

We could examine gaps in victim services, improve trauma-informed communication and expand long-term support for families.

We could evaluate whether our violence prevention investments are producing meaningful results.

We could strengthen partnerships among law enforcement, schools, behavioral health providers, neighborhood organizations and community-based violence intervention programs.

And we could make the prevention of violence as visible a public priority as the punishment of those who commit it.

That would be a meaningful way to honor victims.

Not by forgetting what happened to them, but by learning from those tragedies and accepting a greater responsibility to the people whose lives remain at risk.

Why This Matters Today

The debate over California's death penalty is about more than the fate of 548 people convicted of serious crimes.

It is about what we believe justice requires of us.

It is about how we respect victims, exercise governmental authority, protect the innocent, and hold people accountable for devastating acts of violence.

But it is also about the future.

In Sonoma County, we know the names Polly Klaas and Frank Trejo because their lives ended in violence. We remember the seven people murdered by Ramon Salcido because their deaths left wounds that still resonate.

We should remember them.

We should honor their lives, acknowledge the suffering of their families, and never minimize the gravity of the crimes committed against them.

But remembrance alone is not enough.

If we want to honor those who have died, we must also demonstrate an enduring commitment to protecting those who are still living.

That means investing in prevention, strengthening victim services, supporting effective law enforcement, and recognizing that public safety involves more than responding to crime after the damage is done.

It means asking difficult questions about what works, what does not, and where our resources and attention can make the greatest difference.

It means understanding that justice is not a single verdict, sentence, or act of punishment.

Justice is also the work we undertake to protect human life, reduce suffering and create communities where people can live without fear.

This brings us back to Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel's observation that "in a free society, some are guilty, but all are responsible." Those who commit acts of violence bear responsibility for their crimes. But the rest of us cannot escape our own responsibility to confront violence, support those who have suffered, and do everything reasonably within our power to prevent future tragedies. We may not share the guilt, but we share the obligation to act.

Sheriff Engram reminds us that justice must mean something.

He is right.

I believe that principle calls us to consider something more.

Justice must mean more than what happens to someone who takes a life. It must also mean what we do to protect the next life that might otherwise be lost.

We owe that responsibility to victims and their families.

And we owe it to the children, families, neighbors and public servants whose names we do not yet know — and whom we hope will never become the subjects of another tragedy.

The question before us should not be limited to how severely we punish those who have committed terrible acts.

It should also be how seriously we are prepared to work together to prevent the next one.

If we can summon such extraordinary determination to punish a murderer after a life has been taken, shouldn't we summon at least as much determination to prevent that life from being lost in the first place?

Next
Next

When Cancer Changes the Woman You Love, What Kind of Man Will You Be?